ROI on a property in Egypt: how to calculate it, and how it differs from return on equity (ROE)

ROI on a property is your net gain (sale proceeds plus net rent, minus everything you paid) divided by everything you paid. Because a property is held for years, convert it to an annual rate before comparing. ROE answers a different question: the yearly net income relative to the equity you actually own in the unit.

An investor next to a large phone with a rising chart and a building model

The Corporate Finance Institute defines ROI as the benefit an investor gets relative to the cost.

The formula

Count every cost, then make it a yearly rate.

Net gain = (Sale price - selling costs) + total net rent received - total cost of buying ROI % = Net gain / Total cost of buying x 100 Annual ROI % = ((Ending value / Total cost of buying) ^ (1 / years) - 1) x 100 where Ending value = net sale proceeds + total net rent received

Total cost = contract price plus registration, finishing, furnishing and extras. The source also flags maintenance, property taxes, sales fees and legal costs.

Basic ROI ignores time: 50% over 3 years equals 50% over 5 years. Use annualized ROI, the third line.

Worked example

Illustrative example with hypothetical numbers.

ItemAmount (EGP)
Contract price2,000,000
Fees, finishing and other buying costs200,000
Total cost of buying2,200,000
Net rent per year (after costs)120,000
Holding period5 years
Total net rent over 5 years600,000
Sale price after 5 years2,800,000
Selling costs50,000
Net sale proceeds2,750,000
Net gain = 2,750,000 + 600,000 - 2,200,000 = 1,150,000 EGP ROI = 1,150,000 / 2,200,000 x 100 = 52.3% Annual ROI = ((3,350,000 / 2,200,000) ^ (1/5) - 1) x 100 = 8.8% per year

52.3% divided by 5 is 10.5%. Wrong: it ignores compounding.

Monthly rent makes the true rate a little higher. Precision needs a dated cash flow.

ROI vs ROE

  • ROI: the whole deal, start to sale. Was it worth it?
  • ROE: one year. How hard is your money working now?

The source defines ROE as net income over shareholders' equity. For a unit, equity is value minus what you still owe.

Equity = Property value - Remaining debt (installments or loan still owed) Average equity = (Equity at start of year + Equity at end of year) / 2 Net income = Rent - operating costs - financing interest - taxes Annual ROE % = Net income / Average equity x 100

ROE example on a unit still being paid

Illustrative example with hypothetical numbers, for a delivered, rented unit.

ItemStart of yearEnd of year
Property value2,000,0002,000,000
Remaining installments1,200,0001,000,000
Equity800,0001,000,000
Average equity = (800,000 + 1,000,000) / 2 = 900,000 EGP Net income = 120,000 rent - 20,000 costs - 0 interest - 0 tax = 100,000 EGP Annual ROE = 100,000 / 900,000 x 100 = 11.1% Same income on the full value = 100,000 / 2,000,000 x 100 = 5.0%

Same income: 5% of the value, 11.1% of your money. Both are right.

Value is held flat on purpose. A value change moves equity, not income.

Common mistakes

  1. Counting only the contract price.
  2. Using gross rent, not net (see the rental yield guide).
  3. Comparing a 3-year ROI with a 7-year ROI without annualizing.
  4. Dividing total ROI by the years.
  5. Treating a hoped-for sale price as known. Test a lower one.
  6. Calling ROE ROI. High ROE with heavy financing means more debt.

What to ask before trusting the result

  • What does the price include? Which fees, deposits or finishing are extra?
  • When is delivery? No rent before it.
  • How much is unpaid at each year end?
  • Is the rent a signed lease or an estimate?
  • What does selling cost (broker, transfer, developer resale terms)?

Frequently asked questions

Is a higher ROI always better?

No. Compare annual ROI; an optimistic sale price adds risk.

Include the maintenance deposit in the cost?

Yes, if you pay it to own. Check the contract for a refundable part.

Why is ROE higher with installments?

The denominator is your smaller equity. The installments are still owed.

Can ROE be negative or unavailable?

Yes. Costs above income make it negative; debt at or above value makes it meaningless.

Which one for off-plan?

ROI for the whole plan. ROE once the unit earns.

Run the numbers

CalcRealty has ROI, annual ROE and payment plan calculators. Download CalcRealty on Google Play, free, in Arabic and English, in Egyptian pounds.

See the New Cairo guide, the North Coast guide and the total cost of ownership guide.

Results are planning estimates; the developer contract sets the final amounts.

Read next: off-plan vs ready units and the real estate glossary.

Sources

  1. Return on Investment (ROI), Corporate Finance Institute,
  2. Return on Equity (ROE), Corporate Finance Institute,

Read next